Ireland Tightens Rules on Insurance Claim Settlements
TLDR: Ireland isn’t just capping payouts anymore, it’s rewiring who gets to set them. A new bill pulls some authority away from the Judicial Council, a government action plan is comparing Irish awards against the UK and Europe, and court jurisdiction limits are rising so fewer claims end up stuck in the High Court.
What’s Actually Changing
For years, the story in Ireland was simple: the Personal Injuries Guidelines, brought in back in 2021, pushed down what courts could award for pain and suffering, and the numbers dropped hard. But 2026 is a different conversation. The latest figures from the Injuries Resolution Board show the median award actually climbed to €14,020 in 2025, up from €13,100 the year before, even with the guidelines still firmly in place.The Injuries Resolution Board said the median award in 2025 was €14,020, up from €13,100 in 2024. That’s still well below pre-guidelines levels, but it’s moving the wrong way for insurers who were promised steady declines.
So the government isn’t tweaking numbers this time. It’s changing the machinery that produces them.
Why Settlement Values Are Shifting
Claim volumes are actually down, not up. The Board received just over 20,000 applications in 2025, continuing a trend that’s seen filings fall well below pre-pandemic levels.The board received 20,077 claim applications during the year, a 4% fall compared with 2024 and 35% lower than pre-pandemic levels in 2019. Fewer cases, bigger average payouts. That combination is what’s got the Department of Justice paying attention.
Special Damages Are Doing the Heavy Lifting
The guidelines only ever touched general damages, the pain and suffering portion of a claim.The guidelines, introduced in 2021, apply only to general damages, which cover pain and suffering arising from an injury. They were never designed to touch special damages, the actual medical bills and lost wages. And those have been climbing fast, tracking inflation and rising treatment costs rather than any legal formula.The rise in the median award was driven by higher special damages, including medical expenses and loss of earnings, which are more closely linked to inflation and living costs. That’s the gap insurers are now trying to close through policy, not litigation.
The Push to Rebalance How Guidelines Get Set
This is where the real tightening shows up. The general scheme of the Judicial Council (Amendment) Bill 2026 was published this year, and it changes who controls the guidelines going forward.The general scheme of the Judicial Council (Amendment) Bill 2026 has been published and proposes further reforms to the process under which the personal injuries guidelines are set.
Judicial Council Loses Some Control
Under the proposed changes, the Council will have to consult the Injuries Resolution Board and other stakeholders before any guideline revision, and it will be required to actually research how Irish award levels stack up internationally before making changes.The Judicial Council will also now be required to consult with the Injuries Resolution Board and other stakeholders when reviewing the guidelines, and to conduct research on damages for personal injuries, including on how Irish awards compare internationally. Separately, the government’s own action plan on insurance has set out 26 actions, with a formal benchmarking exercise comparing Irish payouts to the UK and the rest of Europe.The Action Plan sets out 26 actions, including a benchmarking exercise to examine levels of Irish personal injury awards compared to the UK and other European jurisdictions. In plain terms, nobody in government wants Ireland’s numbers drifting out of line with its neighbors, and they’re building the paperwork to prove it either way.
Courts Are Getting a Shakeup Too
Settlement isn’t only about award size. It’s also about where a case lands, and that’s shifting too. The Civil Reform Bill 2025 is being described as one of the biggest overhauls of Irish civil justice in decades, aimed at cutting delay and cost.The Civil Reform Bill 2025 represents one of the most significant and comprehensive overhauls of the Irish civil justice system in decades, aiming to streamline court processes, reduce delays and costs, and enhance access to justice.
Higher Limits Mean Fewer Cases in the High Court
The bill would raise the District Court’s ceiling from €15,000 to €20,000, and lift the Circuit Court’s limit for personal injury claims from €60,000 up to €100,000.The Bill proposes raising the District Court’s jurisdictional ceiling from €15,000 to €20,000, while the Circuit Court’s monetary limit would increase from €60,000 to €100,000. That pushes a lot of mid-value claims out of the High Court entirely, into cheaper, faster venues. Fewer claims in the expensive courtroom usually means fewer claims dragging on for years before anyone sees a settlement.
What This Means If You’re Filing a Claim
None of this changes the math on an existing claim overnight. But it does mean the ground is moving. Expect slower guideline revisions now that there’s a mandatory consultation step, expect more claims routed through mediation (which already settled 54 percent of cases last year), and expect special damages, not general damages, to be the number worth watching closely over the next year or two.

